THE 2026 BUYING GUIDE

Best Refrigerator with Ice Maker 2026
Our top 5 reviewed picks

A refrigerator with an ice maker must fit your kitchen before it can fit your routine. Kenmore 75525 is our narrower-kitchen starting point; Midea MRF29D6AST adds much more storage and two ice makers. Decide whether you want freezer-bin ice or water and ice through the door, then check the complete installation dimensions.

These five research-based reviews cover full refrigerators with included ice makers, not countertop machines or replacement kits. We checked exact retail variants against manufacturer documents and flag conflicting claims. We have not measured cooling, ice production or reliability. Delivery availability, installation, water connections and local service should be confirmed before purchase.

Research-based reviewsOur scoring approach

Scores compare these five on a relative 9.0-9.9 shortlist scale, not an absolute quality scale.

Meet the five picks

ChooseRight earns a commission when you buy through some retailer links on this site, at no extra cost to you. Check the current price and availability with the retailer.

THE SHORTLIST

Five picks. A clear reason for each.

Compare your picks

Choose the stated use before the score. Our relative 9.0-9.9 ChooseRight Scores describe documented shopping factors, not test results or guaranteed outcomes.

  1. Pick #01
    Kenmore 75525, 17.5 cu. ft.
    For a narrower kitchen opening

    Kenmore 75525, 17.5 cu. ft.

    You need a narrower French-door refrigerator with automatic ice.

    Why choose it
    Factory-installed ice in a narrower format
    Main compromise
    Smaller storage capacity
    Read the review
    9.8/10
    ChooseRight Score
    See new listings on eBay
  2. Pick #02
    Samsung RF18A5101SR/AA, 17.5 cu. ft.
    For recessed handles and counter-depth fit

    Samsung RF18A5101SR/AA, 17.5 cu. ft.

    You prefer a shallower cabinet with recessed handles.

    Why choose it
    Recessed handles reduce protruding hardware
    Main compromise
    Limited capacity for large households
    Read the review
    9.7/10
    ChooseRight Score
    Check price at Abt
  3. Pick #03
    Midea MRF29D6AST, 29.3 cu. ft.
    For large storage and two ice makers

    Midea MRF29D6AST, 29.3 cu. ft.

    You have room for a large cabinet and want two ice sources.

    Why choose it
    Dual ice makers and external dispensing
    Main compromise
    Large cabinet and delivery requirements
    Read the review
    9.5/10
    ChooseRight Score
    Check price at Electronic Express
  4. Pick #04
    BLACK+DECKER BRF1600GIMB, 16 cu. ft.
    For a smaller black-finish kitchen fridge

    BLACK+DECKER BRF1600GIMB, 16 cu. ft.

    You want a compact full-size French-door model in black.

    Why choose it
    Built-in ice maker in a smaller format
    Main compromise
    Smallest capacity in this selection
    Read the review
    9.4/10
    ChooseRight Score
    See new listings on eBay
  5. Pick #05
    Kenmore 75625, 28.6 cu. ft.
    For external cubed or crushed ice

    Kenmore 75625, 28.6 cu. ft.

    You want large storage and easy through-door ice access.

    Why choose it
    External cubed/crushed ice and water
    Main compromise
    Standard-depth according to manufacturer catalog
    Read the review
    9.3/10
    ChooseRight Score
    See new listings on eBay

5 of 5 selected for comparison

Compare selected

SIDE BY SIDE

Compare the details that change your purchase.

Published specifications and exact retail listings
Comparison of the 5 selected products
Your shortlistKenmore 75525, 17.5 cu. ft.Samsung RF18A5101SR/AA, 17.5 cu. ft.Midea MRF29D6AST, 29.3 cu. ft.BLACK+DECKER BRF1600GIMB, 16 cu. ft.Kenmore 75625, 28.6 cu. ft.
Best suited toNarrower kitchensCounter-depth fit with recessed handlesLarge grocery loads and frequent ice accessSmaller household; black finishLarge-family storage with dispenser access
Total capacity17.5 cu. ft.17.5 cu. ft.29.3 cu. ft.Approximately 16 cu. ft.28.6 cu. ft.
Cabinet formatNominal 30-inch; counter-depth32 1/8-inch width; counter-depth36-inch class; standard-depthFrench doors with bottom freezer36-inch class; maker lists standard-depth
Ice accessFactory-installed freezer-bin iceAutomatic freezer-bin iceDual ice makers; cubed/crushed dispensingBuilt-in freezer ice makerCubed and crushed dispensing
DispenserNo through-door dispenserNo external ice dispenserExternal water and iceNo through-door dispenserExternal filtered water and ice
Before orderingHandle depth, door swing and water lineInstallation clearance; app requirementsResolve dimensional and output discrepanciesFood storage versus ice-bin spaceRetail counter-depth claim conflicts with maker
ChooseRight Score9.8 / 109.7 / 109.5 / 109.4 / 109.3 / 10

Scores compare documented buying factors within this shortlist. They do not establish safety, efficacy or performance guarantees. Choose by intended use first.

Source review: October 28, 2026. No hands-on cooling, ice-output, acoustic, energy-use or reliability tests. Conflicting primary/retailer installation specifications are identified rather than resolved by guesswork.

A closer look

The five picks, in detail

What stands out. What to consider.
Who each pick makes sense for.

Pick #01
For a narrower kitchen opening

Kenmore 75525, 17.5 cu. ft.

Shortlist

For a narrower kitchen opening

Research-based review · Sources checked

Evidence behind this review

Exact retail listing and cited manufacturer documentation; suitability judgments are editorial inferences.

No hands-on cooling, ice-output, acoustic, energy-use or reliability tests. Conflicting primary/retailer installation specifications are identified rather than resolved by guesswork.

Kenmore 75525 is our starting point for a narrower kitchen that needs a full refrigerator and a factory-installed ice maker. Its nominal 30-inch width and 17.5 cu. ft. capacity offer a smaller footprint than the large family models below, with ice collected inside the freezer.

The stainless finish, French doors and two-tier freezer drawer give you separate access to refrigerated and frozen storage. Kenmore describes crescent-shaped ice and advertises up to four pounds per day; that is a manufacturer capacity claim, not our measured output. There is no through-door ice or water dispenser.

Counter-depth does not mean flush without planning. The published depth changes when handles are included, and doors need clearance to open and remove drawers. Before ordering, compare the installation drawing with the opening and delivery route, and confirm that your water connection and retailer installation service cover this exact model.

Why this score? 9.8/10

Relative ChooseRight Score: 9.8/10. Underlying weighted rubric: 9.0/10.

Storage & ice suitability9.1/10 · 40% of rubric
Factory-installed ice and narrower width address a clearly defined kitchen need.
Installation & ownership8.7/10 · 35% of rubric
Organized storage and simple ice access are useful, but capacity and handle clearance constrain fit.
Buying clarity9.1/10 · 25% of rubric
Exact manufacturer model and ice-maker inclusion are documented.

ChooseRight Scores reflect the weighted criterion gaps, with a 9.0 floor and a 9.8 or 9.9 lead. Equal assessments can tie. These are relative positions, not absolute quality grades or measured performance margins. Read the rubric.

Best suited to
Narrower kitchens
Total capacity
17.5 cu. ft.
Cabinet format
Nominal 30-inch; counter-depth
Ice access
Factory-installed freezer-bin ice
What we like
  • Factory-installed ice in a narrower format
  • French-door access and freezer drawer
  • No external dispenser occupying a door
Worth considering
  • Smaller storage capacity
  • Open freezer to collect ice
  • Handles add to installed depth
Choose it if

You need a narrower French-door refrigerator with automatic ice.

Consider an alternative: Choose Midea MRF29D6AST for more storage and external dispensing.
Before you buy
Does it dispense water through the door?

No. This model has freezer-bin ice, without a through-door water or ice dispenser.

Is installation included?

Do not assume it. Check the seller's water-hookup, delivery, haul-away and installation terms for your address.

Pick #02
For recessed handles and counter-depth fit

Samsung RF18A5101SR/AA, 17.5 cu. ft.

Shortlist

For recessed handles and counter-depth fit

Research-based review · Sources checked

Evidence behind this review

Exact retail listing and cited manufacturer documentation; suitability judgments are editorial inferences.

No hands-on cooling, ice-output, acoustic, energy-use or reliability tests. Conflicting primary/retailer installation specifications are identified rather than resolved by guesswork.

Samsung RF18A5101SR/AA suits a kitchen that needs a counter-depth French-door refrigerator with recessed handles and automatic freezer-bin ice. It offers 17.5 cu. ft. of total capacity in a different shape from the narrower Kenmore, so measure both rather than choosing on capacity alone.

The US specification sheet lists dimensions of 32 1/8 inches wide, 70 inches high and 28 1/8 inches deep with hinges and doors. These are cabinet planning dimensions, not the complete installation opening. The freezer has an automatic ice maker; there is no external ice dispenser to serve a glass without opening it.

SmartThings connectivity is optional convenience that requires Wi-Fi and an account for app features. Do not make a connected alert your only food-temperature safeguard or assume every internet outage produces a useful notification. Choose this model for physical fit and storage first, then check the exact service and warranty terms offered in your area.

Why this score? 9.7/10

Relative ChooseRight Score: 9.7/10. Underlying weighted rubric: 8.8/10.

Storage & ice suitability8.9/10 · 40% of rubric
Automatic ice and recessed handles suit the counter-depth use, with limited total storage.
Installation & ownership8.6/10 · 35% of rubric
Physical layout is straightforward; freezer access and smaller capacity remain compromises.
Buying clarity9.0/10 · 25% of rubric
US primary specification sheet identifies dimensions and automatic ice maker.

ChooseRight Scores reflect the weighted criterion gaps, with a 9.0 floor and a 9.8 or 9.9 lead. Equal assessments can tie. These are relative positions, not absolute quality grades or measured performance margins. Read the rubric.

Best suited to
Counter-depth fit with recessed handles
Total capacity
17.5 cu. ft.
Cabinet format
32 1/8-inch width; counter-depth
Ice access
Automatic freezer-bin ice
What we like
  • Recessed handles reduce protruding hardware
  • Automatic freezer ice maker
  • Published US dimension sheet
Worth considering
  • Limited capacity for large households
  • No through-door ice service
  • App features require connectivity and account
Choose it if

You prefer a shallower cabinet with recessed handles.

Consider an alternative: Choose Kenmore 75525 if the narrower width fits your opening better.
Before you buy
Does it include an ice maker?

Yes. The US specification sheet lists an automatic ice maker in the freezer.

Do I need an app to use the refrigerator?

Basic refrigeration does not depend on using the app. Remote smart features require the stated Wi-Fi and account setup.

Pick #03
For large storage and two ice makers

Midea MRF29D6AST, 29.3 cu. ft.

Shortlist

For large storage and two ice makers

Research-based review · Sources checked

Evidence behind this review

Exact retail listing and cited manufacturer documentation; suitability judgments are editorial inferences.

No hands-on cooling, ice-output, acoustic, energy-use or reliability tests. Conflicting primary/retailer installation specifications are identified rather than resolved by guesswork.

Midea MRF29D6AST is the large-household option when storage and access to both external ice dispensing and a freezer ice supply matter. It has 29.3 cu. ft. of advertised capacity and two ice makers, so it serves a different kitchen than the smaller counter-depth choices.

The external dispenser offers water plus crushed and cubed ice. A sliding shelf and adjustable door-bin arrangement help accommodate taller containers. The manufacturer identifies the replacement filter as MIWF8200, making filter availability a useful check before committing to this appliance.

Midea's current product page, specification sheet and manual do not present one consistent overall depth or daily ice-output figure. We therefore do not promise a single clearance dimension or guaranteed production rate. Obtain the exact current installation drawing and revision from the seller, allow for handles and door swing, and remember that two ice makers still need cooling time and a suitable water supply.

Why this score? 9.5/10

Relative ChooseRight Score: 9.5/10. Underlying weighted rubric: 8.7/10.

Storage & ice suitability9.3/10 · 40% of rubric
Dual makers, external dispensing and high storage capacity are strong for the stated large-household use.
Installation & ownership8.6/10 · 35% of rubric
Flexible storage helps, but size and filter/ice maintenance create ownership demands.
Buying clarity7.8/10 · 25% of rubric
Primary-source depth and output conflicts materially reduce purchase certainty.

ChooseRight Scores reflect the weighted criterion gaps, with a 9.0 floor and a 9.8 or 9.9 lead. Equal assessments can tie. These are relative positions, not absolute quality grades or measured performance margins. Read the rubric.

Best suited to
Large grocery loads and frequent ice access
Total capacity
29.3 cu. ft.
Cabinet format
36-inch class; standard-depth
Ice access
Dual ice makers; cubed/crushed dispensing
What we like
  • Dual ice makers and external dispensing
  • Large 29.3 cu. ft. capacity
  • Identified MIWF8200 filter
Worth considering
  • Large cabinet and delivery requirements
  • Conflicting published depth/output figures
  • Filter replacement and two ice systems to maintain
Choose it if

You have room for a large cabinet and want two ice sources.

Consider an alternative: Choose Kenmore 75525 if a narrower installation matters more.
Before you buy
Does dual ice mean unlimited ice?

No. Daily production and stored capacity are finite and depend on operating conditions. We have not tested recovery after the bins are emptied.

Which depth should I use to plan installation?

Request the current model/revision drawing and confirm handles, hinges and clearances. Published primary sources differ; do not plan from a single headline depth.

Pick #04
For a smaller black-finish kitchen fridge

BLACK+DECKER BRF1600GIMB, 16 cu. ft.

Shortlist

For a smaller black-finish kitchen fridge

Research-based review · Sources checked

Evidence behind this review

Exact retail listing and cited manufacturer documentation; suitability judgments are editorial inferences.

No hands-on cooling, ice-output, acoustic, energy-use or reliability tests. Conflicting primary/retailer installation specifications are identified rather than resolved by guesswork.

BLACK+DECKER BRF1600GIMB is the black-finish option for buyers who need a smaller full refrigerator with a built-in ice maker. Its roughly 16 cu. ft. format trades bulk storage for a more compact French-door layout.

The selected retail listing describes 11.15 cu. ft. of refrigerator storage and 5.06 cu. ft. of freezer space. Digital controls let you set the compartments separately, while the freezer ice maker feeds an internal bin. The maker's manual describes production as dependent on freezer temperature, openings and other use conditions.

Plan a cold-water connection and check the exact manual's pressure and tubing requirements with the installer. This is not a self-filling countertop machine and it does not provide through-door ice or water. Its smaller freezer must accommodate both food and the ice system, so compare drawer layout with the containers you actually store.

Why this score? 9.4/10

Relative ChooseRight Score: 9.4/10. Underlying weighted rubric: 8.5/10.

Storage & ice suitability8.6/10 · 40% of rubric
Smaller format with included ice serves a specific household, but storage is constrained.
Installation & ownership8.3/10 · 35% of rubric
Separate controls help; internal ice-bin space and installation add compromises.
Buying clarity8.8/10 · 25% of rubric
The exact model family has an available manufacturer instruction manual.

ChooseRight Scores reflect the weighted criterion gaps, with a 9.0 floor and a 9.8 or 9.9 lead. Equal assessments can tie. These are relative positions, not absolute quality grades or measured performance margins. Read the rubric.

Best suited to
Smaller household; black finish
Total capacity
Approximately 16 cu. ft.
Cabinet format
French doors with bottom freezer
Ice access
Built-in freezer ice maker
What we like
  • Built-in ice maker in a smaller format
  • Separate digital compartment controls
  • Black finish option
Worth considering
  • Smallest capacity in this selection
  • Ice bin shares freezer space
  • No external water or ice dispenser
Choose it if

You want a compact full-size French-door model in black.

Consider an alternative: Choose a larger Midea or Kenmore if weekly bulk storage is essential.
Before you buy
Do I manually fill a reservoir?

No. This built-in refrigerator ice maker needs a household water connection as described in its manual.

Will ice be ready immediately after delivery?

No. Installation, cooldown and the manual's first-use procedure take time. Do not schedule a party around immediate first ice.

Pick #05
For external cubed or crushed ice

Kenmore 75625, 28.6 cu. ft.

Shortlist

For external cubed or crushed ice

Research-based review · Sources checked

Evidence behind this review

Exact retail listing and cited manufacturer documentation; suitability judgments are editorial inferences.

No hands-on cooling, ice-output, acoustic, energy-use or reliability tests. Conflicting primary/retailer installation specifications are identified rather than resolved by guesswork.

Kenmore 75625 is a large 28.6 cu. ft. French-door option for families who want water and cubed or crushed ice through the door. It is worth considering when that everyday convenience matters more than a compact cabinet.

The selected stainless-steel listing identifies model 4675625, adjustable storage, a full-width pantry drawer and dual evaporators. A foldable shelf can help with taller containers, while the dispenser gives access without opening the freezer. Confirm the exact replacement filter and its availability rather than treating filtration as a lifetime benefit.

There is a material fit discrepancy: the retail listing calls this counter-depth, but Kenmore's product page classifies 75625 as standard depth, around 36 inches deep with handles. Treat it as a large standard-depth appliance until the current model drawing proves the installation you need. We have not tested dispenser reliability, noise or ice recovery, and the feature list does not establish those outcomes.

Why this score? 9.3/10

Relative ChooseRight Score: 9.3/10. Underlying weighted rubric: 8.5/10.

Storage & ice suitability9.0/10 · 40% of rubric
Large storage and cubed/crushed dispensing address family use well.
Installation & ownership8.5/10 · 35% of rubric
Adjustable shelves improve organization, but large size and dispenser upkeep add demands.
Buying clarity7.6/10 · 25% of rubric
A direct counter-depth versus standard-depth source conflict reduces buying clarity.

ChooseRight Scores reflect the weighted criterion gaps, with a 9.0 floor and a 9.8 or 9.9 lead. Equal assessments can tie. These are relative positions, not absolute quality grades or measured performance margins. Read the rubric.

Best suited to
Large-family storage with dispenser access
Total capacity
28.6 cu. ft.
Cabinet format
36-inch class; maker lists standard-depth
Ice access
Cubed and crushed dispensing
What we like
  • External cubed/crushed ice and water
  • Large pantry and adjustable storage
  • Dual evaporators documented
Worth considering
  • Standard-depth according to manufacturer catalog
  • Listing depth description conflicts
  • Dispenser and filter require maintenance
Choose it if

You want large storage and easy through-door ice access.

Consider an alternative: Choose Samsung RF18A5101SR for a documented smaller counter-depth format.
Before you buy
Is this really counter-depth?

Kenmore's product page lists model 75625 as standard depth, despite the retail listing wording. Use the exact installation drawing, not that marketplace label.

Does the ice rating prove reliability?

No. Our score compares documented purchase factors. We have not measured failure rates or long-term ice-maker performance.

BEFORE YOU CHOOSE

How to choose refrigerators with ice makers

Check the installation opening first, then choose ice access, usable storage and the water connection your home can support.

01 / BUYING ADVICE

Choose the ice format you will actually use

Freezer-bin ice means opening the freezer and scooping. A through-door dispenser is convenient for frequent drinks but adds a chute and parts to clean, and can affect storage layout. Cubed and crushed ice are not the same as nugget ice.

An included ice maker is different from an optional kit. Match the exact model suffix and finish to the seller's offer. Do not assume an ice-maker photo means that a cheaper variant includes it.

02 / BUYING ADVICE

Measure the entire installation

Measure width, height, depth, door swing and the route from the delivery entrance. Include handles, hinges, trim, stairs and space to remove drawers. Nominal 30- or 36-inch labels do not define the complete opening.

Counter-depth is a design description, not a universal measurement. Our Kenmore 75625 sources disagree on that label, and Midea documents differ on depth. Resolve those discrepancies with a current drawing and the installer before purchasing.

03 / BUYING ADVICE

Plan water, filters and first use

These automatic ice systems need the water supply specified in the exact manual. Confirm tubing, pressure, shutoff access and who completes the connection. Delivery, hookup, haul-away and installation are separate services unless the offer explicitly combines them.

Flush and discard first-use water or ice as instructed, and maintain the filter and bin on the manufacturer's schedule. A filtration claim does not mean every contaminant is removed. Identify the replacement cartridge and supported claims for that exact system.

04 / BUYING ADVICE

Assess capacity and service realistically

A maximum daily production figure is not an instant supply or a guarantee in a warm kitchen. Leave room for freezer food as well as the ice bin, and keep backup plans for unusually high demand. We have not measured recovery time or long-term failure rates.

Check local repair coverage, warranty exclusions, replacement filters and the seller's delivery-damage procedure. Compare annual energy labels for the exact model. Smart features and an editorial score cannot replace temperature checks or a suitable installation.

Clear recommendations

How we choose and score

We compared the selected models using manufacturer documentation and exact retail listings. The category rubric measures documented buying suitability and trade-offs, not laboratory results.

ChooseRight Scores use the category-specific criteria and weights below. We retain the full weighted assessment until the final display step. The strongest assessment anchors the list at 9.9 when its underlying rubric is at least 9.1, otherwise 9.8. Other picks lose the same number of points as their gap from that assessment, with a 9.0 floor. We do not force the last pick to a fixed score or assign numbers by rank. Equal assessments can tie. These are editorial comparisons within this shortlist, not absolute quality grades, customer ratings or measured performance.

Storage & ice suitability40%

Documented storage format and ice access matched to the stated household.

Installation & ownership35%

Physical fit, organization, water/filter needs and everyday access.

Buying clarity25%

Exact-model documentation, included equipment and unresolved specification conflicts.

What the underlying rubric scores mean
9.0 to 10
A particularly strong documented offering for the criterion, with limited relevant compromises. A 10 would still not mean perfect for every person.
8.0 to 8.9
Strong capabilities with a meaningful limitation or missing convenience.
7.0 to 7.9
Useful capabilities, but several trade-offs require a more specific buyer.
Below 7.0
A substantial compromise in this criterion, even if other strengths justify a specialist recommendation.

ChooseRight Score = max(9.0, lead score - (highest unrounded weighted rubric - product unrounded weighted rubric)), rounded to one decimal. Lead score is 9.9 for a highest rubric of at least 9.1, otherwise 9.8. The 9.0 floor can compress larger gaps; inspect the criterion values and reasons for the underlying differences. A displayed tenth is editorial precision, not a measured performance margin. Replacing the leading pick can change relative scores.

Distinct reasons to chooseVisible limitationsSources you can check
A few useful answers

Refrigerator ice-maker questions, answered

Who is behind this guide?

Published by ChooseRight. ChooseRight reviewed manufacturer documentation and exact retail listings. No hands-on testing is claimed.

What changed on October 28, 2026?

: Refreshed the original URL with five exact variants, current primary-source checks, category-specific guidance and evidence-linked scores.

Found the right fit?

Return to our five picks